B.C. Supreme Court in Vancouver. (Black Press Media files)

‘No smoke, no fire’ defense says in conflict case that could kick three off Langley Township council

Lawyers argued there’s no evidence of any conflict or vote-for-money deal

There is no evidence of any link between campaign contributions to Langley Township’s mayor and several councillors, and votes on development projects, lawyers argued Thursday as a hearing that could remove a third of council from office continued in B.C. Supreme Court.

The Dec. 3 hearing was the fourth of arguments in a case pitting 10 local voters against Mayor Jack Froese, Councillors Bob Long and Blair Whitmarsh, and former councillor Angie Quaale.

The voters petitioned the court to remove Froese, Long, and Whitmarsh from office, claiming they were in a conflict of interest for taking campaign contributions from development company executives while developments by those companies were under consideration by council.

Lawyer J.W. Locke, representing the mayor and councillors, said there is simply no evidence of a link between the contributions and the way the officials voted.

“There must be a link beyond mere campaign contributions,” Locke argued. “There is nothing unlawful about giving campaign contributions, that’s well established.”

A promise, implicit or otherwise, to vote in a certain way is required, Locke argued before Justice Paul Walker.

There has to be evidence of such a deal, said Locke.

“I know it may be difficult, but some evidence from somebody who says these votes were tied to these contributions,” he said is required, not just the timing issue. “It’s inferential at best and speculative at worst.”

James Goulden, a lawyer for the Township of Langley, spent some time Thursday laying out exactly how the development process functions, and noting that the vast majority of developments put before the council pass.

He pointed to dozens of decisions, including rezonings, development permit hearings, and heritage alteration permits, and discussed how staff make recommendations to the council.

Councillors only see the rezonings and give their final votes after Township staff have worked with the developers, and final votes aren’t held until after public input. In the case of one of the votes at issue, on the Williams Neighbourhood Plan, the planning and input process lasted for three years.

“There’s no smoke, there’s no fire, there’s nothing wrong here,” said Goulden.

READ MORE: Judge hears Langley development case that could end in mayor, councillors booted out of council

READ MORE: Court challenge aims to remove mayor, councillors in Langley Township

Goulden warned of the impacts to the Township if the councillors should be removed from office.

Not only would that remove one-third of the nine-member council, Goulden said it would call into question all 19 decisions the petitioners are challenging as involving conflicts of interest.

“Those may become a significant issue for the Township,” Goulden said. The rezoning and development decisions could be challenged as well.

Mark Underhill, the lawyer for the 10 voters who petitioned the court, wrapped up with some final arguments saying that there was no need to prove a direct deal or agreement of any kind to vote a certain way in exchange for the campaign cash.

He continued to argue that the close timing between votes and donations was enough, and referenced a number of other conflict of interest cases where councillors voted on matters that impacted their employers, business partners, or non-profits they had been members of.

However, Justice Walker questioned Underhill on that subject.

“It [the conflict of interest] arises from the fact of the relationship,” Walker said, and those links were obvious during the trial. “But in this case, we don’t have those types of relationships. You don’t have any of the mayor or the council members… involved with any of the developers.”

They weren’t employees or investors, they didn’t have family members working for the developers, Walker said.

If there was an issue, wasn’t that a matter for the B.C. Legislature to rule on, Walker asked.

Underhill countered that, if there’s no link between timing and votes, there is nothing to stop a developer from turning up at a council meeting and handing out $400 cheques to mayor and councillors immediately before a vote.

But Walker continued to question if timing was relevant.

“Where is the dividing line?” he said.

What’s the difference between a donation two years before a vote and one just days before a vote, Walker said.

The hearing Thursday finished in the early afternoon, and Walker was to hear a few final arguments on Friday morning before considering his ruling.

READ MORE: Developer donations still coming in Langley Township despite rule change

READ MORE: Langley Township tackles donation controversy

BC Supreme CourtCourtLangleyLangley Township

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Crows gather at in the cottonwoods of Sandra Kidder’s neighbour in Aldergrove every winter morning just before sunrise. (Sandra Kidder/Special to the Langley Advance Times)
SHARE: Aldergrove cottonwoods hosts morning murder of crows

Send us your photo showing how you view Langley, and it could be featured in a future edition

When Langley City resident Dale Attrell, 92, seen here walking in Douglas Park on Saturday, Jan. 10, started a walking club for seniors, it filled up quickly. (Dan Ferguson/Langley Advance Times)
Outrunning COVID: a Langley City senior starts a walking club

When Dale Attrell launched a group for older people to go on walks together, it filled up quickly

Langley’s Jim Orlowski, a regular contributor to Through Your Lens, shared this picture of some bird swimming around in Brydon Lagoon. They were spotted while he was walking along the trail in the Nicomekl flood plains. They frequently cross paths with dozens of other walkers and park visitors enjoying the trail on a bright winter day. (Special to Langley Advance Times)
SHARE: Bird friends from Brydon

Send us your photo showing how you view Langley, and it could be featured in a future edition

Mark Chandler, outside of his extradition hearing at the Vancouver Supreme Court. (Langley Advance Times files)
Langley condo builder’s fraud sentencing in U.S. delayed due to COVID-19

Mark Chandler’s own lawyer contracted COVID-19 in December

Keith the curious kitten is seen on Nov. 4, 2020 at the Chilliwack SPCA. Friday, Jan. 22, 2021 is Answer Your Cat’s Questions Day. (Jenna Hauck/ Chilliwack Progress file)
Unofficial holidays: Here’s what people are celebrating for the week of Jan. 17 to 23

Answer Your Cat’s Questions Day, Pie Day and International Sweatpants Day are all coming up this week

(Phil McLachlan - Capital News)
‘Targeted’ shooting in Coquitlam leaves woman in hospital

The woman suffered non-life threatening injuries in what police believe to be a targeted shooting Saturday morning

sdf
Another Mission student arrested for assault, in 2nd case of in-school violence this week

RCMP notified of local Instagram page with videos (now deleted) showing student assaults, bullying

(Photo by Kevin Hill)
40 cases linked to Surrey Memorial Hospital COVID-19 outbreak

Fraser Health says two death are associated with the outbreak

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

JaHyung Lee, “Canada’s oldest senior” at 110 years old, received his first dose of the COVID-19 vaccine on Thursday, Jan. 14, 2021. He lives at Amenida Seniors Community in Newton. (Submitted photo: Amenida Seniors Community)
Standardized foundation skills assessment tests in B.C. schools will be going ahead later than usual, from Feb. 16 to March 12 for students in Grades 4 and 7. (Black Press Media file photo)
B.C. teachers say COVID-affected school year perfect time to end standardized tests

Foundational skills testing of Grade 4 and 7 students planned for February ad March

Sooke’s Jim Bottomley is among a handful of futurists based in Canada. “I want to help people understand the future of humanity.” (Aaron Guillen - Sooke News Mirror)
No crystal ball: B.C. man reveals how he makes his living predicting the future

63-year-old has worked analytical magic for politicians, car brands, and cosmetic companies

A unique-looking deer has been visiting a Nanoose Bay property with its mother. (Frieda Van der Ree photo)
A deer with 3 ears? Unique animal routinely visits B.C. property

Experts say interesting look may be result of an injury rather than an odd birth defect

Most Read