Shelley and Ray Murphy told Township council it isn't fair to force them to pay for a water hook-up they don't need based on a tie vote of residents.

Tie vote means yes, residents discover

Fight over water service vote ends in defeat for opponents despite deadlock

By Dan Ferguson, Black Press

Some residents who objected to a proposed water service connection have learned a tie vote means yes in the Township of Langley —  and every other B.C. municipality.

Even though the Township sent out letters saying more than 50 per cent of property owners would have to vote for a costly hookup to a new municipal water line to approve it, it turns out the provincial laws say something else.

It was the second poll of the residents of 52 Avenue between 237 and 240 Streets about connecting to the under-construction East Langley Water Supply line.

The first vote was more than 50 per cent in favour, but it was thrown out after residents Shelley Murphy and Ray Murphy pointed out five of the responses were filed on or after the deadline date.

The written Township notice said the voting forms must be filed “before June 12, 2013,” not “on or before,” the usual wording used in Township documents.

The Murphys said the proposal should be considered defeated.

Township staff did not agree.

On their recommendation, council ordered another vote.

Before the second vote in August, the Township sent out a July 17 notice that “more than” 50 per cent of property owners would have to vote yes for the hookup to be approved.

The vote was a tie, with 20 owners voting for and 20 voting against.

A Sept. 13 Township letter said that was actually a win for the hookup because the Community Charter, the provincial regulation that governs such votes, says “at least” 50 per cent must vote yes for approval.

“That’s not fair, Shelley Murphy told council Monday night (Sept. 30)

“It should have been a failed vote the first time and it should be a failed vote this time.”

She said her family doesn’t need the hookup because it has a well.

Murphy said a yes will saddle them with a taxes-included bill of about $30,000 that will have to be repaid over 20 years.

Another resident, Mike Parker, supported the Murphys, calling the cost of the water connection “unbelievable.”

A third speaker, Ken Kostiuk, expressed support for the hookup, saying the cost will be balanced out by savings on electricity and maintenance for his well pump.

Resident Bob Sangha said having grown up in a village with no water, he supports the improvement.

“We can’t stop progress,” Sangha said.

Mayor Jack Froese said while it was “unfortunate” that letters had been sent out suggesting it would take more than 50 per cent, the regulations are clear.

“The charter is the law of the land,” Froese said.

The hookup was approved by a seven-to-two vote.

Shelley Murphy was indignant.

“You ought to be ashamed of yourselves” she said as she walked out of council chambers.

The $33.5 million East Langley Water Supply project to bring Metro Vancouver water to Aldergrove and Gloucester is the biggest project ever undertaken by the Township of Langley’s engineering department, with 14 kilometres of water main and a booster pump station.

Just Posted

New Langley City mayor’s gala dedicated to Mom

Val van den Broek partners with Mounties to raise money for women’s health care at Langley hospital

PHOTOS: First look inside Aldergrove’s new FreshCo

Aldergrove got its first taste of the Sobeys’ franchise on Thursday

VIDEO: Gun scare at Walnut Grove Secondary school was ‘unloaded pellet gun’

Police called in after photo circulated on social media

Thief boosted cash registers in Lower Mainland crime spree

Langley, Coquitlam, Burnaby, and New West were all hit, police say

Affordable housing for Langley seniors to open by early 2021

Emmaus Place is a partnership between a local church and goverment agencies

Community uses loophole to paint 16 rainbow crosswalks after B.C. council says no

So far 11 rainbows are painted and five planned, all since council denied the first proposal in September

Adoption centre closes despite effort to save it; B.C. left with two agencies

Choices Adoption and Pregnancy Counselling in Victoria was set to close in April

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh to meet with Trudeau today to discuss throne speech

Top ask will be for Liberal support for the immediate creation of a national universal pharmacare program

B.C. set to announce changes around youth vaping, regulations

Move will involved education, tightening access, working with partners and pressuring the federal government

Yelling at your dog might hurt its long-term mental health: study

Researchers find dogs trained using negative reinforcement are more ‘pessimistic’

Vancouver Island soap company releases Lucky Lager beer soap

Beer-infused olive oil soap comes out just in time for holiday shopping

Jagmeet Singh says he’ll vote against throne speech if NDP requests not met

Singh is to meet with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau on Thursday

Most Read