Retired Hydro flack happy to refute rail boosters

Arguing rages on from both sides in regards reinstating an interurban rail system in the Valley

Dear Editor,

I must respond to [Rail boosters not going away, Langley Advance Times Letters, July 5].

I find it specious that letter writer [Rick Green] finds the TransLink staff actions appalling when they, on several occasions, have politely refuted the rationale behind his and other groups’ requests for resurrecting the old BCER/BC Hydro Fraser Valley Interurban Railway line from New Westminster to Chilliwack for a number of simple and obvious reasons.

The claim of “cost and environmentally effective transportation” by the South Fraser Community Rail Group (SFCRG) is spurious and lacks sufficient analysis to even be presented to the public through the Mayor’s Council on Transit.

TransLink’s studies are not outdated nor flawed and are not “full of falsehoods and misrepresentation of the facts.”

Nor is TransLink attempting “to discredit the public behind this campaign.”

The studies have been carried out by experts; not ex-politicians, transit bloggers and chemical lab assistants.

The SFCRG campaign lacks sufficient analysis especially when it comes to ridership projections among many other aspects of piggybacking on the old BCER/BC Hydro railway line that is heavily used in part by the Canadian Pacific Railway on the way to the Roberts Bank Terminal – a major reason for the line not being suitable for public transportation.

The head of the South Fraser Community Rail Group is a former mayor of Langley Township who failed to get re-elected in 2011 after three years of a distaff relationship with councillors. It seems that SFCRG’s relationship with TransLink has gone beyond distaff and for very obvious reasons – the disdain shown by the SFCRG’s leader and a Rail for the Valley blogger among others.

A “fair hearing” is not justified based on several transit and transportation experts with TransLink examining the paltry submission made by the SFCRG as their “laying out of the facts” is not accurate from an engineering and transit perspective.

READ MORE: Aldergrove envisions what the Valley could look like through UBC students’ blueprints

The group has held six public meetings attended by a handful of benignly ignorant members of the public and one former disgraced premier of B.C.

The attendance at these meetings totals about 0.00002 per cent of the voters in B.C. and 0.00001 per cent of the voters in the Lower Mainland or 0.000005 per cent of the voters in the Fraser Valley and 0.0000025 per cent of the voters in the south side of the Fraser Valley from Surrey to Chilliwack.

TransLink does not have a campaign to ignore the public on the south side of the Fraser River but is politely trying to “educate” the proponents of resurrecting the old Fraser Valley Interurban line who are failing to understand the comprehensive reasons for the old Interurban line never seeing passenger service again.

Threatening TransLink will only lead to polite responses by their senior staff that will eventually lead to SFCRG giving up like four other groups since 2001.

If the SFCRG wants a debate on the issue, I would be glad to meet with them on a stage and go through all the documents provided by them and others, including TransLink, word by word, paragraph by paragraph, page by page, section by section.

G.E. MacDonell, Abbotsford

BCER / BC Hydro Railway historian, presenter and researcher

(Formerly with BC Hydro public affairs division editorial services)

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Donate blood with the Vancouver Giants

Hockey Gives Blood gives fans a chance to donate on Thursday, Jan. 23 at Langley Events Centre

Condo count rises in Aldergrove and ripples of revitalization predicted

Willow Creek’s final phase of condos to be finished by fall, half already sold

Langley teacher witnesses coronavirus terror in Shanghai: ‘everyone is on edge’

Face masks and hand sanitizer ‘sell out’ as 9 SARS-like illness cases confirmed in Shanghai

People who make a difference: Langley residents two of three stars named by Fountain Tire and the Vancouver Giants

Awards honour community members for their volunteerism, humanitarianism and generosity

Youth hit with gun butt during fight at Langley mall

RCMP are investigating the fight between two groups of youths

B.C.-based firefighting plane crashes in Australia, killing three

Three people are confirmed dead in the crash in New South Wales

B.C. privacy commissioner suggests media civility for Prince Harry and Meghan

Lawyers for the Duke and Duchess of Sussex reportedly sent a letter to British press threatening legal action

Victoria’s plastic-bag ban ended by Supreme Court of Canada

City’s leave to appeal lower court’s decision denied

One person in Vancouver being monitored for coronavirus, feds say

Federal Health Minister Patty Hajdu said five or six people are being monitored in Canada

Gap between cost of legal and illegal cannabis keeps growing: Stats Canada

In B.C., legal pot cost $9.32 per gram when bought legally

The word ‘landlord’ is too negative, one B.C. councillor says

Coun. Dave Loewen says term should be replaced by ‘rental housing provider’ in new housing strategy

Police looking for two men after guns stolen from New Westminster home

Guns were secured properly at the time of the theft, police said

Canada prepares as WHO decides whether to declare global coronavirus emergency

The city of Wuhan, China, has shut down outbound flights and trains

Survey finds support among Canadians for broader assisted-dying law

The survey was conducted Jan. 17 to 21 among 1,552 Canadians eligible to vote

Most Read