LETTER: Township’s $18 million Aldergrove amenity contribution policy is shortsighted

A lack of consultation has led to policy based on bad judgment, retired councillor says

Dear Editor,

Recently, I have followed the evolution of the revised Community Amenity Contribution (CAC) policy which was adopted by Council at its April 15 meeting.

This Council did not even wait for the original CAC Policy (passed on July 23rd, 2018) to come into effect to see what the implications and ramifications of implementing a policy of this nature might do, both from a growth perspective, and also from a development industry perspective.

Rather than take a wait and see approach, the new council simply threw out that document and raised the CAC fee by 20 per cent, a cost fronted by new home buyers.

The Feb 29 report to Council stated, “The proposed revisions would require consultation with the Development Industry for information and feedback.” That was completely ignored, and a motion to have the Urban Development Industry speak to Council was passed, 8-1, with the only developer on Council voting against having his industry spokespersons present.

Regardless, Council passed the new policy without any feedback from the industry or the TOL community as a whole, including the Willoughby Community Association.

I thought in this era of “New Beginnings,” transparency and open government were paramount… not so.

The policy states, “The provision of these amenities will be subject to community input, Council prioritization, and available revenue.”

We know that the community had no input on the changes to the policy, but what about the issue of available revenue? The headline in the paper read $18 million will be generated from this new CAC to enhance Aldergrove’s downtown core.

The social media response was euphoria. But is this just a ruse to get a new four-storey parkade paid for without Aldergrove community input?

The housing industry is in a downturn due to a number of factors. This policy does not contribute to the revenue source, only rezoning applications – and there is a graduated 12-month grace period. In other words, it will take considerable time before the new Amenity Fund achieves a usable sum.

The interesting feature of the new policy is that it is directly tied to growth in our community: the greater the growth, the greater the revenue generated. Ironically, two members of Council (sometimes three) who whole-heartedly supported the new CAC Policy vote against virtually every new rezoning application that comes up!

In order for Aldergrove to get $18,000,000 in the next 20 years, there will have to be 24,032 new single-family dwellings built. That is 1,201 homes built per year in the TOL.

That thresholds increases significantly when you mix the townhouses and condos, as they generate much less revenue.

I suggest it is impossible in a downturn market.

So what are the priorities for the redevelopment of Aldergrove’s downtown core?

One Council member’s “fix” is a 188-stall four-storey parkade right in the middle of the new mall redevelopment. The cost estimate I received from one industry person was $30,000 per stall – for a total of $5,640,000.

The parkade concept is already built in to the plans for the updated Aldergrove Mall application, and will soon be fast-tracked to Council for a height variance. The Mall plan, as shown to the public in March, incorporates it – and you have had no say in the matter.

In the meantime, the TOL will have to borrow the money, pay the interest until there is enough money “in the bank.”

Is this the best and highest use of the CAC amenity money? Is this a true model for public consultation?

Everyone on Social Media is really excited for Aldergrove, until the time comes when Willoughby or Brookswood need access to that 11 per cent for a new police station, library, or community recreation facility.

With the new building in Brookswood that will contribute the revised CAC fund in 10 years, that business core could use an upgrade – but the money is tied up to go towards Aldergrove. Poor planning.

My only hope is that Council will start to take a closer look at the numbers and input process, and all the people that are taken in by a headline start to look deeper, do the math, and really consider if a four-storey parkade truly is the highest priority for Aldergrove’s revitalization.

I hope the Aldergrove Community Association has lots of “Thank-you” cards to send to every new household built in the Township, starting at the close of the grace period. Those newcomers will be paying for Aldergrove’s parkade and other improvements.

Charlie Fox, Aldergrove

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Langley residents and musicians remember Gabby’s Country Cabaret

Nightclub showcased local talent, connected friends, and even hosted a wedding during its 34 years

Surrey RCMP promise enforcement at unofficial show ‘n’ shines

Cars have been impounded at the site in the last two years

UPDATE: Gabby’s Country Cabaret announces ‘heartbreaking’ permanent closure

Owner Steve Gallagher ‘holds out hope’ of a new future for the 35-year-old nightlife hotspot

Summerset organizers aim to appeal restriction to continue with Langley drive-in festival

A recent provincial health decision, no more than 50 vehicles are permitted to gather for B.C. events

VIDEO: Workout Wednesday with Brand Fitness

Week eight circles back to focus on the chest and back muscles

B.C. retirement home creates innovative ‘meet-up’ unit for elderly to see family face-to-face

Innovative ‘purpose-built’ unit keeps residents safe when seeing family for first time since COVID-19

Facing changes together: Your community, your journalists

Thanks for helping the Aldergrove Star to continue its mission to provide trusted local news

Fraser Valley libraries to offer contactless hold pick-ups

FVRL Express — Click, Pick, Go service to be offered at all 25 locations starting June 1

B.C.’s essential grocery, hardware store employees should get pandemic pay: retail group

Only B.C.’s social, health and corrections workers are eligible for top-ups

Edmonton, Vancouver and Toronto vying to be NHL hubs, but there’s a catch

The NHL unveiled a return-to-play plan that would feature 24 teams

B.C. sees 9 new COVID-19 cases, one death as officials watch for new cases amid Phase Two

Number of confirmed active cases is at 244, with 37 people in hospital

Nanaimo senior clocked going 50 km/hr over limit says her SUV shouldn’t be impounded

RCMP say they can’t exercise discretion when it comes to excessive speeding tickets

United Way allocating $6.6M in federal funding to help with food security, youth mental health

Applications from Fraser Valley and Lower Mainland charities being accepted for the emergency funding

Illicit-drug deaths up in B.C. and remain highest in Canada: chief coroner

More than 4,700 people have died of overdoses since B.C. declared a public health emergency in early 2016

Most Read